Santa Rosa buyers say they were forced to give up their agents, and now they are suing
A Sonoma County lawsuit accuses one of Northern California's largest real estate brokerages of pushing homebuyers into dual agency deals that left them worse off.
By Naledi Dlamini ·

Claudia Ochoa and Cesar Gonzalez were ready to make an offer on a newly built home on Santa Rosa's west side when they were told to drop their real estate agent. To bid on the house, near their children's school, they would instead have to work with an agent from W Real Estate, one of Northern California's largest brokerages and the same firm representing the developer. First-time buyers with three young kids, they assumed this was just another quirk of California homebuying.
Two years later, they call it illegal. The married couple is part of a Sonoma County lawsuit accusing W Real Estate and its owner, Randy Waller, of shunting buyers into dual agency transactions, in which the same agent or brokerage represents both buyer and seller.
Dual agency is banned in more than half a dozen states. California allows it only with the informed consent of both parties, and the suit argues these buyers had no meaningful choice. "You can't try to get the highest price for the seller and also try to get the lowest price for the buyer, it's an inherent conflict of interest," said Wayne Bell, a former commissioner at the California Department of Real Estate.
The suit, filed earlier this year, says hundreds of buyers across at least five new developments were left worse off: less likely to receive seller credits and concessions, and in some cases never warned of shoddy construction now the subject of separate litigation. Four legal experts not involved in the case told CalMatters the allegations, if accurate, raise serious ethical if not legal questions.
Waller referred questions to his attorneys. Lawyer Doug Pettit said in a written statement that the company cannot discuss specifics while the case is pending but "disputes the allegations," adding that its agents benefited buyers and that all buyers "had the right to consult with different agents if they wanted." A jury trial is scheduled for next May.
Documents and emails unearthed in the case spell out the arrangement. A listing agreement with City 44 developer Dan Morgan states that "W Real Estate shall represent both buyer and seller in all transactions." Another document offered an outside agent a 2.5 percent referral fee for bringing in a client, then stepping aside. "An outside agent would not act as a buyer's agent," agent Nalishma Carvelho wrote to one prospect, telling another the setup was "pretty common" in Sonoma County. Carvelho did not respond to requests for comment.
Stephen Flynn, the attorney bringing the suit, said paying a buyer's agent to go away is not something he has seen in 20 years of real estate law. "That's a level of brazenness that is quite astonishing to me," he said. Kerrin Shettle, a veteran Petaluma agent who signed one of the contracts, recalled being told: "You're not involved, so we need you to stop being involved."
Flynn said sales data produced in discovery put a price on the practice: at one W Real Estate development where dual agency was not required, buyers with their own agents were four times more likely to get concessions such as waived closing costs, and received nearly six times more on average, $3,252 versus $554. Plaintiff Danny Matranga said construction delays pushed his 2022 closing past a near doubling of interest rates, costing him more than a thousand dollars a month, before he found water damage and other defects in his City 44 home.
Court records show a City 44 construction superintendent's text warning that buyers were "being sold homes that are substandard" was shared with both Morgan and Waller. Morgan said in a statement that valid concerns are being addressed through the legal process, and Pettit said the brokerage "was not aware of any construction defects at any developments that its agents hid from buyers."
Consumer advocates call the case an extreme version of a national worry. Industry consolidation has made Compass the country's largest brokerage, and its private listing networks have drawn congressional inquiries, state probes and lawsuits. "Private listing is a way to basically create a mechanism for dual agency," said Zillow chief economist Mischa Fisher. Compass said its goal is seller flexibility, not double-ended deals, and that all its listings are publicly available through the company. Shown the Sonoma complaint, Wendy Gilch of the Consumer Policy Center said: "Oh gosh, this case is bad."
Originally published by News Media House
More News · Santa Rosa news · Report a business · Got a Story?






