California Death Penalty Remains in Law After Newsom’s Mass Clemency
San Bernardino prosecutors intend to keep seeking death sentences as Newsom’s clemency decisions and a constitutional challenge reshape capital punishment in California.
By Naledi Dlamini ·

California’s death penalty remains available to prosecutors despite Gov. Gavin Newsom’s move last week to commute 548 death sentences, leaving a divide between state law and the likelihood of executions. San Bernardino County District Attorney Jason Anderson is among the prosecutors who say they will continue pursuing capital punishment in appropriate cases, even as opponents seek a court ruling that could halt new death sentences.
California has carried out no executions since 2006. Newsom imposed a moratorium in 2019, later dismantled San Quentin’s execution chamber and moved condemned prisoners to other facilities. Most prisoners covered by his clemency requests were awaiting lawyers for appeals and other legal challenges. Only 45 faced imminent execution if the moratorium ended, an unlikely prospect because Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra had also pledged not to conduct executions during his term.
Voters rejected abolition and approved a measure intended to accelerate executions in 2016. Capital punishment remains legal in roughly half of U.S. states, but California permits it under broader circumstances than any other state, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. Qualifying crimes include killings of police officers, prosecutors and other public officials, along with murders connected to gangs or financial gain.
Anderson opposed Newsom’s commutations and says the moratorium does not change prosecutors’ authority to seek death sentences. He discusses the possibility that an execution will never occur with murder victims’ families when considering capital charges. His office has secured death sentences against five men since the moratorium began. Prosecutors in Los Angeles, Riverside and Orange counties have also said they will continue seeking capital punishment when appropriate.
Another San Bernardino County case could soon produce a death sentence. Louis Gabriel Lucero of Victorville pleaded guilty this year to murdering his girlfriend and her two children in 2020. A jury recommended death in October, and a judge is scheduled to decide in December between that punishment and life imprisonment without parole. Lucero could become one of the first people sent to death row after the clemency action.
Of 40 condemned prisoners from San Bernardino County, nine received automatic commutations. The California Supreme Court must review the remaining 31 because they had multiple felony convictions. Anderson has asked for their criminal records to be made public during that review. He argues Newsom should have considered cases individually. In an open letter explaining his decision, Newsom said he had weighed offenses and offenders’ characteristics but learned from victims that each experienced their loss as the worst possible.
Death penalty opponents are also pursuing a constitutional challenge brought by the NAACP, the American Civil Liberties Union and the State Public Defender’s Office. The plaintiffs argue that racial disparities in capital sentencing violate California’s constitutional protections against discrimination. Citing four decades of sentencing data, they say Black murder defendants are up to 8.7 times more likely to receive death sentences than other defendants, while cases involving white victims are 8.8 times more likely to produce death sentences than those involving nonwhite victims.
The state Supreme Court allowed the challenge to proceed in August, and a Sacramento County court is hearing evidence. Plaintiffs want an order preventing counties from imposing death sentences. ACLU attorney Avi Frey said a victory would leave capital punishment in state law, but counties seeking to pursue it would first have to demonstrate that they had corrected racial inequalities.
Natasha Minsker of the California Anti-Death Penalty Coalition said advocates will press prosecutors such as Anderson to stop seeking death sentences. She identified San Bernardino and Riverside as among the nation’s 10 counties that most frequently pursue capital punishment. Other reform advocates hope the commutations will shift attention toward rehabilitation, crime prevention and expanded financial and mental health support for victims.
Originally published by News Media House
More News · San Bernardino news · Report a business · Got a Story?






