Lawsuit challenges HUD rule affecting 7,700 mixed-status residents
Public Counsel filed suit Monday night to stop a December mandate requiring federal housing tenants to prove immigration status.
By Amira Saleh ·

Los Angeles law firm Public Counsel filed a federal lawsuit Monday night to block a new U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development rule. The regulation takes effect in mid-December and requires all residents of federally funded public housing to prove qualifying immigration status to remain in their homes.
The rule changes decades of policy that allowed family members with different immigration statuses to live together in subsidized housing. Under the new mandate, individuals without specific legal status, including recipients of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, do not qualify for federal rent subsidies. They are considered ineligible to live in publicly funded housing despite paying prorated monthly rents.
HUD Secretary Scott Turner defended the change in an online statement released before the rule was finalized. "President Trump warned that the days of illegal aliens and ineligible noncitizens exploiting government-funded welfare programs would be over," Turner said. He added that American taxpayers would no longer foot the bill while eligible residents wait for units.
The Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, or HACLA, stated that 7,700 individuals in the city live in mixed-status households within public housing. HACLA serves over 67,000 households, making it the largest low-income housing provider in Los Angeles. The authority said it is reviewing the final regulation and assessing its operational requirements.
Public Counsel filed the suit on behalf of three Los Angeles residents identified only by their initials. One plaintiff, J.L., is 24 years old and has lived in a HACLA-run apartment for 15 years. She resides with her two brothers, mother, and stepfather in a three-bedroom unit that costs $2,700 per month. J.L. and her siblings are U.S. citizens, while her parents are undocumented.
J.L. works as a pharmacy technician and said her parents rely on her for daily activities such as translating during doctors' appointments and purchasing groceries. The family has feared leaving their home amid increased immigration enforcement activity in the state. "Causing a lot of stress and anxiety because overnight we're not going to have a place to live," J.L. said in the lawsuit.
HUD estimates that 79,300 members of mixed-status families lived in public housing nationwide as of 2024. That total includes 7,190 households in California. The agency’s analysis noted that mixed-status families generally pay higher rents because only eligible members receive discounts. HUD predicted that the new rule would lead to a decline in the number of families receiving assistance.
The agency’s analysis stated that it expects fear of family separation would prompt most mixed families to depart public housing. "The primary effect would be to assist proportionally fewer households and household members, but with higher subsidies," HUD wrote. Public Counsel attorneys argue that HUD lacks the authority to make this change and that power rests with Congress.
Attorney Amanda Mangaser Savage said the new rule could worsen the existing affordable housing crisis. "You're gonna have more demands for shelters and other services, and that's going to impact not just the families that are displaced but everybody else who relies on those services," she said. The lawsuit seeks to halt the rule before it takes effect in mid-December.
More News · Los Angeles news · Report a business · Got a Story?






